My puppy loves crinkle sounds, so he’s obsessed with this toy. It has been his favorite for a very long time. And it has withstood the test of time despite daily play. My puppy tore up his bed and most of his other toys because he likes playing with the stuffing, but this toy is still going strong 3 months later! From this aspect, I would give it 5 stars.As a snuffle/foraging toy however, it fails to meet expectations. The velvro grips on the bottom are useless, and it is very easy for a dog to pull out the treats you hide in the octopus legs because they can pick up the toy and shake everything out. As a snuffle toy, I give it 1.5 stars.My Doberman puppy is about 50lbs and she loves the purple octopus; maybe a little too much. She had ripped most of the treat holes so now when we try to hide the treats and roll up the tentacles they kind of just fall out.My dog loved this toy, but ended up ripping through it while trying to get the food. Super fun and interactive just make sure you’re monitoring your dog while they are using it or they may rip through it.I like it but it’s not very durable. My dog ripped it quite a bit the first time using it just with normal dog use (how you’d expect a dog to try to get the food).Product is a cool idea and my dog loves it. The only negative is after abt 1-2 months of use, the velcro is not holding well any longer.Just as described and my dog loves to play with it when there are no treats in it. The size is perfect and it's durable though I don't have a large dog so it may be different with a large dog for tugging on. The treats part is perfect and takes my very intelligent dog a good amount of time to sniff out and get to. Great distraction.This is a fun toy and my dog likes it, it’s not really a difficult toy to figure out. Easy to put together and goes in the laundry to clean. The openings for food and treats are small, so this is probably better suited for a small dog. Mine is 60 pounds and likes this, but can’t always get food out.Our dog loves this toy and it kept him busy for 3 nice chunks of time. But after 3 uses all of the holes are chewed too wide to hold treats anymore. I wish it would have held up just a little longer.